Twisted Perceptions Continue

City columnist dwells in agriculture fear mongering

Submitted by Will Verboven Ahead of the Heard

A column in the Calgary Herald by regular columnist, Naomi Lakritz, has taken agriculture fear mongering to new heights. The columnist wrote about farm worker rights implying that Bill 6, the legislation mandating WCB coverage for farm workers, would be repealed by a future United Conservative Party government (UCP). She is right about that – a future UCP government would repeal it, along with other NDP inspired legislation – that’s just what happens when you change governments. She implies that Alberta will then return to the dark ages with farm workers again having no rights. That is not going to happen. This is 2017, not 1917, and WCB, OHS and labour standards are here to stay; they will just be covered by new legislation that will more fairly define the rights of both farm workers and employers. Present labour legislation passed under Bill 17 features regulations that so favours one side that it poses a real threat to the viability and working culture of farming and ranching and has been a shock to the ag industry. But that is no surprise – one of the main goals of NDP governments is to change labour laws to favour the unions that prop them up.

What was rather egregious in the offending Calgary Herald column was the fear mongering angle the columnist took. Here are some quotes: “Their lives (hogs) were more important than those of the men because to the farmer they represented money.”; “…take Alberta back to those regressive days when pigs were treated better than their human caretakers.”; and “… some people must be abused, exploited, injured or killed so other people can make money.” All that maliciousness is aimed at hard-working farmers and ranchers and disparages their integrity and dignity. Clearly the columnist knows nothing about commercial agriculture and takes her cue from anecdotal stories about exceptional cases. Yes, it’s true that like any other economic sector that employees people there are bad apples in the ag industry, and horror stories exist that need to be addressed. But this is not done by painting the entire industry as being made up of evil capitalists who treat their workers like slaves. The fact is, as any successful employer in animal agriculture will tell you, their success is based on dedicated, safe and motivated workers and healthy and humanely-treated livestock. Without that approach, an ag employer wouldn’t be able to keep any employee or stay in business. The reality is that most farm and ranch owners/managers are farm workers themselves and quite understand the safety issues involved.

The offending column causes one to ponder how effective the public relations campaign has been that tries to advocate for the positive contribution agriculture makes to society. I would suggest that one such negative column in an urban newspaper can wipe out much of the positive image of animal agriculture that producers and their organizations have tried to portray for years. The column writer has written several columns about the plight of farm workers, but always with some fear mongering, and an unwillingness to look at both sides of the issue to see how things could be resolved fairly for all stakeholders. She admits to attending a union-sponsored farm worker event at the University of Calgary, which explains her biased approach. I wonder whether any producer groups have attempted to reach out to her to at least try to present the other side. For instance – did you know that statistically, farm worker accidents on commercial operations in Alberta have been declining at a faster rate than in the rest of the country, and that started prior to the imposition of the present NDP government labour legislation. I expect the columnist had no idea of that fact. Problems do remain and there are still too many accidents, especially involving farm family members and Hutterite Colonies, but progress is being made.

There is no turning back on farm worker rights; legal and constitutional repercussions will guarantee that political reality. What I expect will happen with a future UCP government is that they will carry out the common-sense negotiation process that the NDP government should have done by dealing directly with producer organizations such as the AgCoalition, the major ag industry safety group. This will result in new, realistic and innovative agriculture-related WCB/OHS legislation that will be a fair compromise to both sides. Curiously, that sounds rather like “collective bargaining”, a process a union-influenced NDP government should have been familiar with, but which seems to have escaped them when dealing with the agriculture industry on this

Just Posted

Another successful year of Stettler Wildcats rugby

Program features a great number of rugby scholarships and provincial level involvements

Officials declare July 13th as ‘Collector Car Appreciation Day’

Collector Car Appreciation Day was launched back in 2010

Local woman recalls potentially deadly injury from mowing the lawn

Shannon McTavish underwent extensive surgery after metal piece lodged in her neck

AMBER ALERT: Alert cancelled after child located safe and unharmed

Alert cancelled after child located safe and unharmed

Children’s book marks literary first for former Stettler resident

Loree Dittrich is celebrating the release of her first book for children called No Home for a Pigeon

VIDEO: ‘Avengers: Endgame’ to be re-released with new footage

‘Avatar’ holds global box office record at $2.788 billion, while ‘Endgame’ stands at $2.743 billion…

More than 700 wildlfire evacuees in Alberta can soon return to Metis community

Evacuees from the Paddle Prairie Metis Settlement can safely return starting on Thursday

B.C. files second legal challenge against Alberta over turn-off-taps law

B.C. government filed a second lawsuit against Alberta on June 14

Tax credits, penalizing big polluters, key to Conservative climate plan

Canada’s commitment is to cut emissions to 70 per cent of what they were in 2005 before 2030

VIDEO: Acknowledging skeptics, finance minister vows to build Trans Mountain project

Bill Morneau said he recognizes ‘huge amount of anxiety’ in Calgary over future of oil and gas sector

Shovels could be in the ground on Trans Mountain by September, CEO says

Ian Anderson points to weeks likely required for NEB to reinstate 2016 regulatory record

Calgary man facing charges after B.C. police service dog aids in arrest

Heavy police presence results in PSD Jagger finding suspect

RCMP allows officers to grow beards

Members can now wear beards and goatees, as long as they’re neatly groomed

Wildfires have forced more than 9,000 people from homes in northern Alberta

People in other communities remain on evacuation alert and could be told to leave quickly

Most Read