Political hyprocrisy or sophisticated evolution

American philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson wrote that “a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesman and philosophers and divines.

American philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson wrote that “a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesman and philosophers and divines. With consistency a great soul has simply nothing to do.” MPs’ great souls have been busy these days. They have been changing their minds on many issues, notably; Mr. Ignatieff’s promise to balance the budget without tax hikes, and Mr. Harper’s appointments to the Senate. Voters will be left to judge whether these and other changes of heart were high-minded or callous.

Every day people change their minds. This is often seen as a good example of a maturing person, especially when the motives for the change are clear and reasonable. Why is it, then, that voters are hard on politicians who change their minds?

Perhaps it is because politicians change their minds too often on too many issues and they do it too quickly. As well they too often fail to disclose any, or at least believable motives for the change of heart. Often the motive is a mathematical calculation of maximizing vote gains. Further, the politician is seen not to believe the new position held.

Both Mr. Harper and Mr. Ignatieff provide good examples.

Mr. Ignatieff says he can no longer support the government given its handling of the economy. This is peculiar given the government is only doing what the Liberals, NDP and Bloc urged them to do last Christmas, when the opposition threatened to topple the Tories for not spending enough. In fact, Mr. Ignatieff voted in favour of the budget he now decries. The motives for this change of heart are less than clear.

In May, the Liberal leader clearly refused to reject the prospect of tax hikes as a measure to aid in balancing the budget. Now he (thankfully) categorically states that no tax increases will even be considered. This change of heart has occurred in less than three months and its motive is also unclear. Perhaps he sees that his ‘bosses’ – the voters – wanted him to change his mind and he has responded to that pressure.

Prime Minister Harper’s ‘great soul’ is also quite busy these days. He has provided a good number of interesting inconsistencies. In the past Mr. Harper has been a staunch critic of large, growing and expensive government, including; corporate welfare, regional development, spending growth and deficit financing. However, the last budget saw him embrace them all – and with gusto. Many Tory apologists argue that the motive for such inconsistency arose from efforts to appease the opposition. Some have said he is also appeasing Tory spending doves as well.

In the end, evaluations will be left up to voters regarding politicians who change their minds on policy matters. Acceptance or rejection of inconsistencies may hinge on whether the position the politician newly embraces furthers or harms the interests of any particular voter. If furthering the interests, the voter may see the change of heart as ‘sophisticated evolution’. If the new position is deemed to be contrary to the interests of a particular voter, he may deem it ‘hypocrisy’.

In the end, Emerson may be right, at least, that the prevalence of so many inconsistencies keeps politicians, and voters, very busy.

Just Posted

Cannabis today more potent than decades ago: AHS

50 per cent of Albertans have tried cannabis

Stettler Scotia Bank holds barbecue

Raises money for MS Society

Stettler RCMP ask public’s help in identifying suspect

Suspected of stealing from Stettler business

Friends help colour-blind woman see colours

Pitch in to buy her Enchroma glasses

CP rail workers give strike notice

Employees could walk out as early as Tuesday at 7 p.m. PT

Vote points to abortion being legalized in Ireland

Voters asked whether to keep or repeal Eighth Amendment to Roman Catholic Ireland’s Constitution

Canadian soccer officials talk up World Cup bid at Champions League final

Current bid calls for 2026 World Cup games to be staged in the U.S., Canada and Mexico

WATCH: Alix holds 2nd annual Icebreaker Roughstock

Many come out to see some intense rodeo action

B.C. RCMP swoop in to save injured eagle

An eagle with a broken wing now in a recovery facility after RCMP rescue near Bella Coola

Bug spray 101: Health Canada wants you to stay bite free

Health Canada is reminding Canadians to use bug spray and other insect repellents safely

Former B.C. premier says pot industry about to enter Wild West

Mike Harcourt says Canada is about to enter a new gold rush with many dreaming of striking it rich

Hunt continues for two suspects in Ontario restaurant explosion

The explosion left 15 people injured, but all victims have now been released from hospital

Most Read


Weekly delivery plus unlimited digital access for $50.40 for 52 issues (must live within 95 kilometers of Stettler) Unlimited Digital Access for one year for $50.40 Prefer to have us call you? Click here and we’ll get back to you within one business day.