Facts sting bee crisis allegations

If editorials in the Toronto and Calgary mainstream media are to be believed, bee populations are about to collapse

If editorials in the Toronto and Calgary mainstream media are to be believed, bee populations are about to collapse and the planet’s food supply will soon be devastated with mass starvation soon to follow. They blame the bee crisis on the use of pesticides most notably a type called neonicotinoids (neonics). That pesticide is applied to seeds to prevent damage from a variety of pests. It is the most widely used pesticide in the world and banning it would result in reduced yields and the increased use of other more toxic pesticides.

The main allegation against neonics is that it kills bees that come into contact with the pesticide. As expected there are studies that try to make the connection, but laboratory experiments are one thing and reality in the field is another. Allegations are made of bee colony losses of up to 40 per cent with the assumption that it must be due to neonic use on crops. Indeed bee colony losses do occur and vary from year to year and region. For example, around 2000, there were significant losses due to the varroa mite killing bees. Many recent large losses are attributed to very cold winters; bees just froze to death as they are housed outside in hives. The problem is none of those mundane problems are very sexy for the big city media or overzealous donation-chasing green lobby groups.

Pesticides always seem to be the universal whipping boy in food related issues so when neonics were alleged to be one of the causes of bee losses, green lobby groups jumped on the bandwagon. Their media machines went into overdrive alleging that bee colonies were about to disappear and it was all the fault of neonics. Many implicated the Monsanto company as the evil force conspiring to rid the world of bees, which probably surprised those folks since virtually all neonics are manufactured by other companies. It would seem the urban media couldn’t resist the onslaught of bee disaster hysteria from green lobby groups and they began to write inflammatory stories and editorials.

But there is one inconvenient truth to the bee disaster story – that being there is no bee population loss crisis, certainly not in Canada. The Canadian Association of Professional Apiculturists stated that the honeybee population has steadily increased since 2009. In Canada there were 611,972 colonies in 2009 and 677,824 colonies in 2013 an increase of 10.7 per cent. Even in Ontario, where much of the crisis story is centred, had an increase of almost 20,000 colonies. The Canadian Honey Council states that there isn’t a bee population crisis and that beekeepers are managing any losses quite well. They note that there are variations from time to time, but the biggest losses are attributed to not surprisingly -very cold winters. The President of the Council also states that bee numbers are increasing and it’s a positive story thanks to best management practices to cope with pests and disease. Clearly something is amiss in the city media reporting of this situation.

It would seem that those responsible for the stories about the alleged bee disaster neglected to contact folks in the actual bee and honey industry who would know the real story first hand. To be fair, agriculture is a mystery to most city journalists and they may have succumbed to the well-oiled green lobby media machines. The other reality is that today the media is subject to the competitive pressure of producing instant news. In addition, agriculture producer associations also tend to be slow in getting their side of story out in a timely fashion. By that time the issue tends to be history and the damage is done.

It should be said that there is considerable concern within agriculture about any deleterious impacts from pesticide and herbicide use. Manufacturers and growers are constantly trying to improve the products and application methods. But there are a couple of important principles that govern the use of chemicals in food production -those being – don’t kill the customer and it must be cost effective. A compromise in the issue may be to use neonics in a much more targeted approach rather the present blanket use method. But an even bigger economic threat to the North American bee and honey industry is the continuing increase in cheap honey imports from China. Considering the abysmal food safety record of that country perhaps that is where the real concern should be. Unless that potential threat is addressed bee numbers will indeed decrease drastically.



Just Posted

County council writes off certain Botha accounts

Council hears public library saw 60,000 pass through doors this year

Stettler secondhand charity looks for new home

Superfluity lease not being renewed; will move by Sept., 2018

First auction of 2018 has solid numbers: auction market

Stettler Auction Mart sees 700 head move through Jan. 9

Stettler and area youth jump into curling this winter

Junior Curling Program runs Monday nights in Stettler

Lars Callieou to entertain in Halkirk on Feb. 10

Volunteer appreciation supper held on Friday night

Stettler and area youth jump into curling this winter

Junior Curling Program runs Monday nights in Stettler

Toronto mayor wants city to co-host 2026 FIFA World Cup

The mayor of Canada’s most populous city says he wants Toronto to be among the North American cities to co-host the 2026 FIFA World Cup

With a lighter touch, SAG Awards follows a familiar script

Morgan Freeman accepts the Life Achievement Award at the 24th annual Screen Actors Guild Awards on Sunday

S. Koreans burn Kim’s photo as N. Korean band leader passes

South Korean activists burned a large photo of Kim Jong Un as an extremely popular girl band passed them

Trudeau heads to Davos to pitch investment opportunities in Canada

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is on his way to Davos, Switzerland for the annual World Economic Forum

A look at potential Canadian nominees for this year’s Oscars

The nominations are to be revealed Tuesday morning for the 90th Academy Awards

Tom Brady leads Patriots back to Super Bowl, top Jaguars 24-20

New England to face winner of Sunday night’s game between Minnesota and Philadelphia on Feb. 4

Liberals quietly tap experts to write new paternity leave rules

Ideas include creating an entirely new leave benefit similar to one that exists in Quebec

Insurers say Canadian weather getting hotter, wetter and weirder

Average number of days with heavy rain or snow across Canada has been outside norm since spring 2013

Most Read

Weekly delivery plus unlimited digital access for $50.40 for 52 issues (must live within 95 kilometers of Stettler) Unlimited Digital Access for one year for $50.40 Prefer to have us call you? Click here and we’ll get back to you within one business day.