Checkoff battle at an impasse, but there’s still hope for a deal

As of press time this week, there was still no indication as to the fate of the mandatory $1 national cattle checkoff.


As of press time this week, there was still no indication as to the fate of the mandatory $1 national cattle checkoff.

Time was running out, as there’s a deadline to meet for government regulations to be put into place to renew the mandatory checkoff.

The stumbling block is the memorandum of agreement (MOA) between the Alberta Cattle Producers (ABP) and the Alberta Cattle Feeders Association (ACFA), which governs the political aspects of the $1 national checkoff. The problem is those two groups tend to have different perspectives on industry issues, and this is no exception.

For the innocent who are unaware of this endless checkoff drama, the MOA was hobbled together three years ago by the two cattle-producer organizations and the agriculture minister of the day. The MOA was to address a major government administrative blunder that imperiled the overall national cattle checkoff, including the impending checkoff on beef and cattle imports — all of which are mandatory.

To deal with that mistake, the first MOA made the $1 checkoff mandatory for three years. With the MOA running out, a new agreement would have to be signed for the mandatory aspect of the checkoff to continue. It was a tenuous compromise at best, and all but guaranteed another round of drawn-out negotiations between the two groups — which is just what has happened.

Discussions between the two groups have been going on secretly for more than six months and there has been agreement on some points.

The proposed MOA has also been expanded in a number of directions, including holding quarterly discussions between the two groups on industry issues.

That’s the good news — the bad news is that the negotiations stalled on agreeing to a new MOA timeline. The ABP proposed a five-year agreement and the ACFA wanted a one-year time limit.

A five-year timeframe would provide some longer-term stability to national funding, and better yet get the topic off the table for a reasonable length of time.

A one-year term might have some strategic benefit for the ACFA and might placate its members that want to terminate the mandatory provision. But the big downside is that a one-year term will guarantee that these tedious negotiations will go on forever.

Considering the major issues that are facing the cattle industry, the last thing cattle producers need is more checkoff discussions. I believe I am expressing the exasperation of many — that 30 years of wrangling on this topic is more than enough — give us all a break.

Sources have indicated that both groups might have gone to Agriculture Minister Verlyn Olson to plead their side of the timeframe issue. The legal reality is that the minister can make an arbitrary decision on the checkoff and does not need the MOA between the two groups to act.

The MOA is an entirely political exercise and was instigated by a previous ag minister to force some unanimity on the industry.

What gets lost in all this is that the government created this political mess in the first place. One can only hope that common sense might prevail with the minister and he makes the mandatory aspect permanent.

That might just force the various factions in the cattle industry to start working on other more important issues and stop beating the checkoff issue to death.

One suspects the minister in examining both sides might just renew the regulations under a new three-year timeframe — the same as before. It’s a political compromise, of course, but at least it will keep Alberta on side with the other provinces as to a mandatory national cattle checkoff. It will also prevent the derailing of a mandatory checkoff on beef and cattle imports.

That new regulation would see $700,000-plus of new checkoff money raised for cattle and beef research and marketing purposes.

That process for imports took over 10 years of slogging and lobbying by provincial cattle organizations and the CCA to achieve. It would be an outrage to see all that effort and funding lost because of any political indecision by the Alberta government.

Will Verboven is the editor of Alberta Farmer.

Just Posted

Alberta Fish and Wildlife Officers ask for the public’s help with unsolved poaching cases

Officers are seeking tips on five separate incidents in the Stettler & Camrose areas in November 2017

Stettler Hospital to host a pregnancy nutrition class later this month

Registered Dieticians will discuss strategies and tips for new and expecting mothers

Stettler Town Council lays out 2018 Strategic Plan

Five priorities identified for the Town to tackle this year

A Look Back – Stettler Independent Archive Files

Originally Submitted By: Margaret Connon and Mary-Jane Jackson Updated By: Landin Chambers

Town of Stettler joins AUMA’s call for more equitable police funding

Letter will be written to local MLA supporting a new police funding model

WATCH: Red Deer celebrates one year out from 2019 Canada Games

Community gathers at Great Chief Park to commemorate Games milestone

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

VIDEO: B.C. deer caught obeying traffic signs

A herd of deer in Fernie, B.C. is getting attention online after stopping for a stop sign

Petition wants fundraiser dropped for family of man cleared in Boushie’s death

Group says GoFundMe is profiting from the young Indigenous man’s death

Porch lights turn on for Canadian teen behind #BeccaToldMeTo movement

New Brunswick’s Rebecca Schofield had asked her Facebook followers to perform random acts of kindness

Calgary man dies in Mexico following sudden illness

Troy Black was with his wife, Lindsay, in Puerto Vallarta when he began vomiting blood on Thursday

Virtue and Moir break their own world record

Virtue and Moir break short dance record to sit first in ice dance at Olympics

New doping charge could hurt Russia’s chance at reinstatement

Russia could lose its chance to be reinstated before the end of the Winter Olympics because of a doping charge against curling bronze medallist Alexander Krushelnitsky.

‘Black Panther’ blows away box office with $192M weekend

In estimates Sunday, Disney predicted a four-day holiday weekend of $218 million domestically and a global debut of $361 million.

Most Read

Weekly delivery plus unlimited digital access for $50.40 for 52 issues (must live within 95 kilometers of Stettler) Unlimited Digital Access for one year for $50.40 Prefer to have us call you? Click here and we’ll get back to you within one business day.