Census questions just who are the ‘real farmers’

Results from the 2011 national agriculture census have been released and they show a confusing picture

WILL VERBOVEN – Ahead of the Heard

Results from the 2011 national agriculture census have been released and they show a confusing picture as to the status of who are farmers in Canada.

The census reports that there are 205,000 farmers in Canada. Out of a population of 34 million that’s just .006 per cent. That low figure actually gets worse if you refine the definition of what constitutes a real full-time farmer.

Statistics Canada hasn’t updated that definition for many decades, which means that farms with less than $10,000 in receipts are also counted. According to the official figures, that’s 20 per cent of the total figure. If you expand that to under $25,000, it’s 37 per cent of all farms.

With all due respect to those folks, they can be classified as hobby farms or part-time operations.

The real meat in the census data are those farms that gross more than $500,000, but they constitute only 11.5 per cent of the total number of farmers — that would mean there are only 23,575 significant commercial farmers in Canada.

It gets even more interesting that there are only 9,600 farms that gross more than $1 million, but that small number produces a whopping 49 per cent of gross farm receipts. None of this comes as a surprise, as the consolidation trend in agriculture has been ongoing for the last 50 years.

It does cause one to ponder at what point does consolidation slow down or stop. So far, there is no indication that it will. For instance, at one time it was thought that a 2,000-acre grain operation was a viable full-time grain operation. Now a commercial operation is deemed to be at least 5,000 acres, if not more.

The same goes for cow/calf operations. You are no longer considered serious unless you have at least a 600-head cow herd as a bare minimum, and even then you had better not have any mortgage in order to survive.

It would seem that there is still plenty of room for consolidation and expansion, particularly in cereal and oilseed operations.

Advances in technology and agronomics continue to push the limits of how many acres a single person can farm.

Much can be read into the farm census data and it could have political and economic consequences, depending on how they are interpreted by governments and the industry.

For instance, farm support programs and industry development programs carried out by governments would probably base their rationales on the 205,000 figure.

But is it realistic spending billions of taxpayer dollars on supporting farmers that are deemed to be small-time operators. Is there any real likelihood that many of those folks will ever evolve into large operators with a half million in receipts.

Again, with all due respect to those hardworking operators, it’s not likely for a number of good reasons.

Another question is — will sending big support cheques to operators that gross more than a million dollars have any impact on the economics of those operations.

Sure, any cheque is welcome, but some lessons from the American experience in that regard are worth noting. In the U.S., when limits were put on how much large commercial farming operations could receive in government subsidies, it was found that virtually all of them continued to operate quite successfully when those subsidies were reduced.

One of the reasons for that is that, in many cases, large operators have much easier access to hedging their costs and returns, and of course had economies of scale. Also, their bankers insisted that they be viable without any long-term dependence on subsidies.

In that situation, any ongoing support programs were usually a lucrative bonus to the operation, rather than critical support. One can understand why governments would be inclined to reconsider their support programs in such situations.

But there is still some political capital left in the overall agriculture industry and governments are more likely to continue their subsidy and development programs, claiming they support not just 205,000 farmers, but additional hundreds of thousands of farm family members and farm workers.

But one can’t help but note that considering the few actual full-time commercial farmers, those government programs could be seen by urban voters as just large rural social programs for most farmers.

That would not be a positive development for agriculture.

Will Verboven is the editor of Alberta Farmer.

Just Posted

Stettler Elementary donates to Red Cross

Funds to help victims of Hurricane Florence

Tips for a stress free Christmas

Easy changes and your family can get back to basics

Our Town Stettler

HMCS Stettler was a River-Class frigate

Castor, Forestburg, coal workers get $257,644 to transition to low-carbon economy

Two transition centres will serve seven communities in the Battler River Region

Trudeau offers to help Pacific islands face climate change impact

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau met with the leaders from the Pacific island nations on Saturday during the APEC Summit in Papua New Guinea

B.C. asking for tips on ‘dirty money’ in horse racing, real estate, luxury cars

Action follows a Peter German report on money laundering in B.C. casinos

Canadian dead more than a week after plane crash in Guyana: Global Affairs

Global Affairs said it couldn’t provide further details on the identity of the Canadian citizen

Privacy concerns over credit card use for legal online pot purchases

Worries follow privacy breaches at some Canadian cannabis retailers

Death toll rises to 76 in California fire with winds ahead

Nearly 1,300 people remain unaccounted for more than a week after the fire began

Trump says report on Khashoggi death expected in a few days

Jamal Khashoggi was a columnist for The Washington Post who was slain Oct. 2 inside the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul

CUPW requests mediator as deadline for Canada Post offer expires without deal

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau weighed in Saturday night with a last-minute plea to the two sides

Trudeau says he won’t negotiate in public on future of LGBTQ rights in USMCA

Legislators urged Trump not to sign the agreement unless the language was removed.

Grande Prairie RCMP charge 19 men, ranging in age from 23 to 69, in prostitution sting

Three-day operation targets sex activities in the downtown area

Most Read